The History of American Baseball and Cincinnati

The First Professional Club

The First Professional Club
The first team made up entirely of professional players was the Cincinnati Red Stockings. Founded in 1866, it was recognized as a fully professional club in 1869. This team, it should be noted, is not the ancestor of today’s Cincinnati Reds.

The First Professional League
The first professional league, the National Association, was established in 1871. Gambling and broken contracts ran unchecked, however, and the league was unable to put its own house in order; it disappeared after the 1875 season. Two of its clubs survive today: the Boston Red Stockings (now the Atlanta Braves) and the Chicago White Stockings (now the Chicago Cubs).

The Birth of the National League
On February 2, 1876, the Chicago businessman William Hulbert founded a new league to set right what the National Association had been. This was the National League. It began with eight clubs, among them the Boston Red Stockings and the Chicago White Stockings mentioned above, along with the Cincinnati Red Stockings, the Hartford Dark Blues and the St. Louis Brown Stockings. This Cincinnati club, too, is not today’s Reds.

The American Association
In 1882 a second league appeared: the American Association. What set it in motion was the expulsion of the Cincinnati Red Stockings from the National League, on the grounds that they had served beer at games and let the ballpark be used on Sundays. Unreasonably enough, the rule in question seems to have been applied before it took effect. The club could no longer keep going and went bankrupt. The plan for a new league was realized through the efforts of an agent acting for its trustee, and a newly formed Cincinnati Red Stockings joined it. That club is today’s Cincinnati Reds.

The American Association lasted until 1891, when financial trouble forced it to disband and merge with the National League. The clubs that came over in the merger, incidentally, were permitted to sell beer.

The Birth of the American League and the Baseball War
The American League came into being in 1901. Its predecessor was a minor league called the Western League, established in 1885. In 1894 a man named Ban Johnson became president of this struggling league. He criticized the rough atmosphere of the National League for keeping families and women away from the ballpark, and set out to make the game welcoming to spectators. Under his management the Western League came to be regarded as the best-run league in the country.

The league was renamed the American League in 1899, and in 1901 Johnson declared that it would operate as a major league. The National League, which naturally regarded itself as the original major league, objected. From there a two-year “baseball war” broke out.

The fighting took the form of raiding players. The National League capped salaries at 2,400 dollars a year, an amount that left popular players dissatisfied. Johnson removed the cap and tempted them across with better terms. More than a hundred players moved to the new league. The American League also placed clubs in the same cities as National League clubs and competed for the same spectators. Lawsuits followed one after another, and mistrust between the two leagues grew without limit.

What settled matters was attendance. The American League drew better in both years, and the National League was the side that sued for peace. In January 1903 the two leagues met in Cincinnati and signed an agreement to respect each other’s contracts. The American League was formally recognized as a second major league, and the structure that continues to this day was born.


Cincinnati

The Cincinnati Reds of today have won nine league pennants and five World Series titles. They had a golden age in the 1970s, but there have been long stretches in the doldrums as well, and they have not won a pennant since 1990. Perhaps for that reason, the club is rarely spoken of as one of the game’s great franchises.


Great American Ball Park, the current home of the Cincinnati Reds

Even so, Cincinnati is indispensable to any account of MLB history. It is the city where the first professional club was born; it is where club names based on “the color of the stockings” began; the expulsion of the Red Stockings from the league gave rise to what is now an everyday sight, drinking beer at the ballpark; and it was here that the feuding National and American Leagues finally made peace, bringing the two-league system into being.

The Cincinnati Reds were also renamed, temporarily, the Cincinnati Redlegs, from 1953 to 1958. “Reds” was a word for communists as well, and the owners feared becoming targets of the Red Scare.


Incidentally, the Cincinnati club first wore red stockings in its amateur days, when it was called the Cincinnati Base Ball Club. It made a bold display of the long-avoided color, set off by knee-length breeches. A reporter at a local paper saw this and mocked them as “the Red Stockings.”

The following year, however, the club took up the nickname itself. It added a red “C” to the chest as well.

At that time about half the roster was made up of players brought in from the East, and it is thought that they were being paid in one form or another. The game was nominally amateur, but in practice clubs everywhere were paying their players under the table — professionals in all but name. Sport in those days was widely regarded as the province of a leisured class, and taking money for it was presumably thought ungentlemanly.

Then, in 1869, the Red Stockings stopped hiding the matter and announced that all ten of their players would be paid a salary. So the first fully professional club in history came into being. That year they toured the country undefeated, and made the name of Cincinnati — and the color red — known across the nation. Over the four seasons from 1867 to 1870 they compiled an astonishing record of 178 wins, 16 losses and 1 tie, a winning percentage of .915.

It was not the ancestor of the Reds, but a club this far ahead of its time in every respect makes Cincinnati, fairly enough, the spiritual home of MLB.



This article contains many of the author's speculations. Also, since the purpose of this article is to generate interest in Infigo online, I will not list any references. Thank you for your understanding.